1Smile Dental | Veneers, Extractions and Pediatric Dentistry

All-on-X vs. Traditional Dentures: Which Is Right for You?

January 26, 2026

All-on-X vs. Traditional Dentures: Which Is Right for You?

If you are missing a full arch of teeth, you have likely explored two primary options: All-on-X dental implants and traditional dentures. While both solutions can restore the appearance of your smile, they differ dramatically in function, comfort, and long-term oral health outcomes.

Choosing the right option depends on your lifestyle, expectations, and long-term goals—not just cost.

At 1 Smile Dental, we specialize in advanced full-arch rehabilitation and help patients across Northwest Indiana and the greater Chicagoland region make informed, confident decisions about their smile.


What Is the Main Difference?

The fundamental difference between All-on-X and traditional dentures is stability.

Traditional dentures sit on top of the gums and rely on suction, adhesives, or clasps to remain in place. Over time, as the jawbone changes shape, dentures can become loose, uncomfortable, and unpredictable.

All-on-X (including All-on-4 and All-on-6) uses strategically placed titanium implants anchored into the jawbone to support a fixed, full-arch bridge. This creates a permanent foundation that closely mimics natural teeth in both function and appearance.

In simple terms:
Dentures rest on the gums.
All-on-X integrates with the bone.


All-on-X vs. Dentures: Comparison at a Glance

Stability
All-on-X: Fixed, secure, no slipping or clicking
Dentures: Removable, may shift during speaking or eating

Bone Health
All-on-X: Preserves jawbone and facial structure
Dentures: Can accelerate bone loss over time

Diet and Chewing Power
All-on-X: Up to 90 percent of natural chewing function
Dentures: Limited to softer foods

Maintenance
All-on-X: Brush and care like natural teeth
Dentures: Daily removal, soaking, and adhesives

Longevity
All-on-X: 20+ years with proper care
Dentures: Typically replaced every 5–7 years


Why “Fixed” Matters: The Quality-of-Life Difference

Many patients come to us after years of frustration with removable dentures—a phenomenon often referred to as “denture fatigue.”

Common concerns include:

  • Difficulty eating in public

  • Speech changes

  • Chronic sore spots

  • Fear of dentures slipping

  • Loss of facial support and premature aging

Because All-on-X implants are anchored directly into the jawbone, they restore stability, confidence, and facial structure. Patients often report that they feel like they have their natural teeth back—not just a replacement.

Beyond aesthetics, implant-supported teeth stimulate the jawbone, helping prevent the sunken facial appearance associated with long-term denture wear.


Understanding the Long-Term Value

Traditional dentures often appear more affordable initially, but the long-term costs can add up. Relines, repairs, adhesives, and repeated replacements are common as the jawbone continues to resorb over time.

All-on-X represents an investment in a permanent, biologically stable foundation. For many patients, the improvement in comfort, function, and confidence far outweighs the upfront difference.

When evaluated over decades rather than years, All-on-X frequently proves to be the more cost-effective and life-enhancing solution.


Are You a Candidate for All-on-X?

If you are experiencing any of the following, All-on-X may be an ideal solution:

  • Loose or failing dentures

  • Severe tooth loss or decay

  • Advanced gum disease

  • Broken or failing crowns and bridges

  • Difficulty chewing or speaking

  • Desire for a permanent, fixed solution

A comprehensive evaluation—including 3D CBCT imaging and digital smile analysis—allows us to determine the most precise treatment plan for your anatomy and goals.


Serving Patients Across Northwest Indiana and Chicagoland

1 Smile Dental is a regional center for advanced implant and full-mouth rehabilitation. We proudly serve patients from:

Northwest Indiana
Schererville
Munster
Highland
Dyer
St. John
Crown Point
Valparaiso
Hammond
Griffith
Merrillville
Chesterton
Portage

Greater Chicagoland
Chicago
South Loop
West Loop
Hyde Park
Bronzeville
South Shore
Oak Lawn
Evergreen Park
Orland Park
Tinley Park
Homewood
Flossmoor

Patients travel to our practice not only for technical excellence, but for a comprehensive, personalized approach to full-arch restoration.

Want a Deeper Understanding of All-on-X?

All-on-X treatment is not a one-size-fits-all solution. The number of implants used, bone quality, bite forces, prosthetic materials, and long-term maintenance protocols all play a critical role in outcomes.

If you would like a comprehensive, step-by-step explanation of:

  • All-on-4 vs. All-on-6

  • Surgical planning and 3D CBCT technology

  • Same-day teeth vs. staged treatment

  • Recovery timelines and aftercare

  • Cost considerations and financing

  • Long-term success and implant longevity

We invite you to explore our in-depth pillar resource:

Ultimate Guide to All-on-X Dental Implants
A complete patient education resource on full-arch implant restoration

This guide was created to help patients across Northwest Indiana and Chicagoland make informed decisions with clarity and confidence—before ever sitting in the chair.

https://1smiledental.com/blog/our-story/2026/14931/all-on-x/


Ready to Explore Your Options?

Choosing a full-arch solution is a significant decision. Whether you are considering All-on-X implants or exploring alternatives to traditional dentures, our team is here to guide you with clarity and expertise.

To learn more about the procedure, recovery, and investment, explore our comprehensive guide to full-arch dental implants.

If you are ready to take the next step, schedule a consultation with 1 Smile Dental and discover what is possible with modern implant dentistry.

Contact Us

We would be happy to answer any questions you have. Just fill out the contact form below and we'll get back to you as soon as possible.

Submit

Call Us

Visit Us

41 US Highway 41
Schererville, IN 46375

Contact Us

Submit